Back in the day Bill Bryson wrote Notes from a SmallIsland. It was the tale of an American travelling around Britain and sharing
his experiences. Twenty years on he has revisited the project in The Road to Little Dribbling: More Notes from a Small Island.
As co-incidence had it I re-read Notes from a Small Island
for a book group I am part of immediately before setting off on The Road for
Little Dribbling. I had enjoyed the
first book but been had been forced to re-evaluate my opinion of Bryson a
little when somebody pointed out he was a little bit rude and not always
politically correct. I was a little taken back by this criticism of Bryson at
first. After all I had been a post-grad at Durham and for part of that time
Bryson had been chancellor and to suggest he was anything less than a minor
deity was really not the done thing. It was probably a good thing I came to
this book ready to more objectively examine the nature of what was being
written a little more.
There are points when Bryson’s opinion is biting and put
forward in a way which is close to cruel. There is also an honesty about his
speech which is not curbed by concerns about what might be politically right to
say. That said it is part of the fun of Bryson and he is now a fully-fledged
grumpy old man I would argue plays up to that in this book.
However, I disagree with the Telegraph writer Clive Aslet who says this
is a made up account of Britain. With regard to Durham Bryson does admit fully
to having a knowledge of the city and he does not for a moment suggest that his
knowledge of the cathedral, which he does say he has visited often, comes from
this visit. I would also say as a frequent train traveller who holidays in the
UK rather than abroad I recognised much of what he said as being true. That
said I do agree with the Telegraph writer that Bryson feigns ignorance on occasion
for the benefit of the laughs. One example being I have no doubt that he
understands the role that the Aldeburgh festival and it’s long association with
Benjamin Britain, together with its close proximity to London play in making it
a sea-side destination that has thrived when others have struggled. It was
where the arty types of the mid-twentieth century chose to escape to before the
younger generation discovered Whitstable.
The distain he feels for British service is sometimes
justified and sometimes not. I would say one only needs to watch the Mary
Portas programmes where she goes in and teaches customer service as an example
of why much of what he says is correct.
In terms of the changing nature of the country and the way
in which some areas are being revitalised whilst others are decaying that is
also not deniable. What I suspect the Telegraph writer dislikes is at various
points, as when he discusses Birmingham, Bryson lays blame at the door of the
government for forcing huge cuts onto local councils.
That is not to say Bryson is a rabid socialist, he is way
too politically incorrect for that. No, he is quite simply a middle of the road
bloke who is taking a look at what is going on and making the same kind of
comments many are when they take the time to look at the impact of the policies
being pursued at the moment.
One of the comforting things I found about this book is I
could imagine my father, who is of a similar age to Bryson making many of the
similar observations.
It is not all doom and gloom though. Bryson is very careful
to give credit where it is due, on occasion naming specific individuals who
have served him well. He also makes, I believe, a fair assessment of the
National Trust which he does join on route.
So do I recommend the book? Yes, if you like grumpy old men
mumbling on and if you want an accurate snap shot of part of Britain at the
moment. No, if you are too easily offended by men of a certain age being at
various points rude, transphobic and generally miserable.
On that last point and referring to page 313 of his book it
did disappoint me that he displayed so much of a lack of understanding about
trans issues. In the unlikely event that (a) he should ever read this & (b)
he should not dismiss me as another one of those book reviewers he dislikes I
should like to invite him to find out more about what it is like for transsexual
people. Preferably by sitting down and just chatting to somebody who is trans
and finding out why referring to “Bruce Jenner in drag” is not a cheap laugh
but really deeply unhelpful and problematic.
No comments:
Post a Comment